Article

9 Marker Essay Plans

Sunday, 17 November 2024

QuestionPointTypeDescription
1. Explain and analyse three ways in which UK political parties select their leaders (June 2022)MP nomination thresholdsExampleLabour requires 20% MP nominations to reach the ballot.
I did not answer this optimally. I should have done one each for each party.AO2Gives MPs strong gatekeeping power → increases unity but limits member choice.
For all examples, they should be the most recent party elections.Membership ballotsExampleLabour uses OMOV; Conservatives let members choose between final two.
AO2Enhances democratic legitimacy → but only after MPs narrow options.
Central party bodiesExampleNEC (Labour) and Party Board/1922 Committee (Conservative) set rules.
AO2Ensures stability and professionalism → but centralises power in leadership.
2. Explain and analyse three ways in which UK political parties allow members to influence policyParty conferencesExampleLabour Conference votes on motions and NPF reports.
Selection would also be a good point.
Party members can select party leadership.
AO2: Quite constrained by the parliamentary party.
AO2Members can pressure leadership → but NEC controls agenda, limiting impact.
Members cannot change policy.
Policy forumsExampleConservative Policy Forum collects ideas sent to national leadership.
AO2Encourages consultation` → but influence is advisory, not binding.
Affiliated groupsExampleLabour trade unions propose motions and vote at Conference.
AO2Union power shapes policy → but can dilute ordinary member influence.
3. Explain and analyse three ways UK political parties select their candidates to be an MPLocal member votingExampleConservatives use special general meetings; Labour CLPs vote via hustings + AV.
Application, shortlisting and selection meeting.AO2Strengthens local accountability → but may favour activists over electable candidates.
Central longlistingExampleLabour NEC longlists; Conservatives require Approved List eligibility.
AO2Ensures quality + diversity → but reduces local autonomy.
Rules for sitting MPsExampleLabour trigger ballot; Conservatives require re-adoption by local executive.
AO2Encourages strong local links → but protects incumbents from deselection.
4. Explain and analyse three functions of political partiesCandidate recruitmentExampleConservative PAB; Labour AWS for diversity.
AO2Ensures trained, suitable MPs → but concentrates power in party structures.
Forming governmentExampleMajority party forms govt; whips maintain discipline.
AO2Enables stable law-making → but reduces independence of MPs.
Policy formulationExampleLabour NPF; Conservative Party Board finalises policy.
AO2Gives voters clear manifestos → but simplifies complex issues.
5. Explain and analyse three ways minor parties impact the political agendaForcing major party policy shifts - “policy agenda”ExampleUKIP pressure → Cameron promises 2016 EU referendum.
UKIP - 2015, 15% of the vote, 1 seat.
SNP - coalition.
AO2Major parties adopt minor party ideas → influence without many seats.
Smaller parties may split the vote, affecting who gets into government.Devolved/local successExampleSNP dominance in Scotland shapes UK agenda (e.g., independence).
Could be better replacing the SNP example with the Liberal Democrats.AO2Regional power allows national influence → forces Westminster concessions.
Shaping public debateExampleGreen Party pushes climate issues into mainstream manifestos.
Weaker example - lesser impact.AO2Media agenda-setting expands discussion → increases policy range.
6. Explain and analyse three key policies of the Conservative PartyLow taxationExampleCommitment to keep income and corporation tax competitive.
Privatisation would have been good: Thatcher, sold British AirwaysAO2Aims to boost growth → but limits government revenue.
Better example: prioritisation of authority, wanted to recruit 20,000Law and orderExamplePledges more police + tougher sentencing.
x - Preservation of the monarchy is another good point.AO2Appeals to security-focused voters → but tackles symptoms not causes.
Controlled immigrationExamplePledges to reduce net migration.
AO2Supports national sovereignty messaging → but may harm labour supply.
7. Explain and analyse three key policies of the Labour PartyPublic service investmentExamplePlans to cut NHS waiting lists via higher funding.
Progressive taxation.AO2Reduces inequality → but expensive and requires tax/borrowing.
Fiscal responsibilityExampleNo rise in income tax; adherence to fiscal rules.
^ replace with taxationAO2Builds economic credibility → but limits policy ambition.
Workers’ rightsExample”New Deal for Working People” strengthens protections.
Workers Rights Act
AO2Supports equality + union ties → may raise business costs.

TODO: Add 3 Labour factions, 3 Conservative factions