Free Will and Determinism
/notes/a-levels/deprecated/psychology/issues-and-debates/free-will-and-determinism/
psychology
issues-and-debates
Article
Free Will and Determinism
Free Will
- The idea that as human beings we are free to choose our thoughts and actions
- This does not deny the idea that there may be biological and environmental factors but says that we are able to reject these forces
Determinism
Hard Determinism
- Suggests that all human behaviour is caused by factors outside of our control
- All human behaviour has a cause that can be identified
- This is in line with the aims of science:
- To find casual laws that govern thought and action
- To assume that everything we think and do is dictate by internal/external forces that we cannot control
Soft Determinism
- Soft determinists also acknowledge that all human action has a cause
- However, they also suggest that there is some flexibility - i.e., People have conscious mental control over the way they behave
- So there are scientific causes that determine our behaviour but we also have freedom to make rational conscious choices in everyday situations
Biological Determinism
- The biological approach emphasises the role of biological determinism in behaviour
- Modern biopsychologists do admit that environment also influences our biological structures but this simply means we are ‘doubly-determined’ in ways we can’t control
Environmental Determinism
- Skinner famously described free will as ‘an illusion’ and argued that all behaviour is the result of conditining
- Environmental determinism is the result of conditioning
- Environmental determinism argues that although we might think we are acting independently, our behaviour has been shaped by environmental events
- It also suggests our behaviour is shaped by the people around us influencing us, e.g., Parents, teachers, etc.
Psychic Determinism
- Psychic determinism sees human behaviour as determined and directed by unconscious conflicts repressed in childhood
- Freud also claimed that free will is ‘an illusion’ but placed emphasis on the influence of biological drives and instincts