Evaluating Brain Imaging
/notes/a-levels/deprecated/psychology/biopsychology/evaluating-brain-imaging/
psychology
biopsychology
Article
Evaluating Brain Imaging
fMRI
- Does not use radiation
- Risk free, non-invasive, straightforward
- Produces images that have very high resolution, showing by the millimetre
- Expensive compared to tother neuroimaging techniques
- Can only capture a clear image if the person is still
- Only measures blood flow in the brain - not a direct measure of neural activity
- Has poor temporal resolution - 5 second lag behind on the image on the screen and the initial firing or neuronal activity
EGG
- Proved invaluable in diagnosis of conditions such as epilepsy
- Contributed to the understanding of stages in sleep
- Extremely high temporal resolution
- Can detect brain activity at a resolution of a single millisecond (or less)
- Information received is very general - from many thousands of neurons
- Not useful for pinpointing the exact source of neural activity
- Cannot reveal what is occurring in deeper regions of the brain such as the hypothalamus
ERP
- Addresses the issues of EEGs
- Brings more specific measurement of neural processes than before
- Isolate neural responses to a stimulus
- Excellent temporal resolution
- Measure how a person processes a stimulus without a person showing any behavioural response
- In order to establish pure data in ERP studies, background noise and extraneous material must be completely eliminated
- Not easy to always achieve
- Small and difficult to pick out from other electrical activity in the brain
- Requires a large number of trails to gain meaningful data
Post-mortem examinations
- Vital for providing foundation for early understanding of brain
- Post-mortem studies improve medial knowledge and help generate hypotheses for further study
- Causation issues - observed damage to the brain may not be linked to the disorder or deficit the individual was thought to have
- may be linked to other unrelated trauma or decay
- Ethical issues - patients may not be able to provide informed consent, e.g., HM who lost his ability to form memories and was not able to provide such consent despite post-mortem research being performed on his brain